Why Happy Workers Aren’t Always Productive Workers

Happy employees are productive employees.

This statement has become something of a mantra among HR and business leaders in recent years, and undoubtedly embodies a core truth. Employees that are satisfied with the terms of their employment and their workplace are more likely to work diligently and productively, and stick around longer, than those who aren’t.

However, while employee satisfaction is a crucial factor, it doesn’t invariably equate to high productivity. In this article, we’ll explore the factors that influence productivity beyond just happiness, giving insights that leaders can use to foster an environment that not only promotes well-being and happiness, but also drives high performance.

Factors Affecting Employee Performance

Employee performance is influenced by a range of interconnected factors, of which happiness or satisfaction is just one. These factors can either enhance or hinder productivity. For example:

• The workplace environment is a key factor; a well-equipped, safe, and nurturing workplace can encourage greater focus and efficiency, while a poorly managed or toxic space can increase stress and disengagement.
• Leadership or management style is another factor, as supportive and well-liked leaders can increase trust and motivation across the team, while the opposite is also true: rigid or neglectful leadership can demoralise employees.
• Individual motivation also has a role to play. Some people are driven by incentives, while others are motivated more by recognition, or by achieving clear goals. Aligning your leadership approach to these motivations can directly impact performance, making employees feel more valued and inspired.
• Training and skills are also important – staff who are equipped with the necessary knowledge and resources to perform their tasks confidently are more likely to be productive than those with skills gaps, who are more likely to become frustrated and make errors.
• Finally, helping your employees to balance their work and personal life is an essential contributing factor to productivity, as burnout from overwork can create resentment and diminish productivity, while the sense of being valued as an individual by their employer can increase morale and output in the workplace.

Does Employee Happiness Have An Impact On Productivity?

Employee happiness is undoubtedly a strong factor in organisational productivity, while also being a positive goal in its own right. There is a vulnerable point, however, in which happiness and satisfaction can slide into complacency and even laziness. In this environment, skills can stagnate or fall behind, and opportunities for growth can be missed. This not only impacts personal productivity but can also undermine morale among teams. Even for the individual employee, this can lead to a sense of being ‘stuck in a rut’, and ultimately, reduce their level of employee satisfaction. Employee satisfaction initiatives work best when they are tied into ideas of productivity and achievement, as this encourages growth and happiness while also maintaining a level of creative friction that enables each employee to strive and develop themselves to their full potential.

Next Steps

With the help of our experiential team and leadership development programmes, your employees can be both productive and satisfied in their roles. To find out more and to see how performance and satisfaction go hand-in-hand to grow your organisation, please contact GRA today by clicking here, or by calling 0118 933 2222.

Image source: Canva